14 Spooky Halloween Trophy Ideas, From Golden Skulls to Haunted Goblets
You can make a trophy worth fighting for with a skull, a goblet and a can of gold paint, as long as the contest is fair and the costumes are safe.
Never miss an update — choose FarmFoodFamily as your preferred source on Google.
How it works: Tap the button below to open Google's settings page, then check the box next to FarmFoodFamily.
Tap the checkbox to turn it blue — that's how you know it's set.
You can make a trophy worth fighting for with a skull, a goblet and a can of gold paint, as long as the contest is fair and the costumes are safe.
Products We Recommend
This post contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Life Size Skeleton Skull for Halloween Decor, White
A life-size plastic skull that becomes the Golden Skull Trophy with a coat of gold paint and a wood base.
Shop Now
FolkArt Acrylic Paint in Assorted Colors (8 oz), Pure Gold
A brush-on gold acrylic for skulls, goblets and pumpkins. Paint outside or in a ventilated space.
Shop Now
Halloween Costume Award Ribbon, Trick or Treat Contest Party Prize
Ready-made award ribbons for a costume contest. Give one to every child so no one leaves empty-handed.
Shop NowThe best Halloween trophies are cheap objects with a gold or black finish and a clear award name. Start with a skull, a goblet or a mini pumpkin.
Glue it to a wood base and paint it. A plaque with the award name makes it feel official, even if the trophy cost very little.
The contest matters as much as the prize.
The Consumer Product Safety Commission says to pick flame-resistant costume fabrics. Skip baggy sleeves, capes and billowing skirts.
FARE says 1 in 13 children in the U.S. have a food allergy, so non-food prizes are a smart pick.
This guide gives 14 trophy ideas, a list of award names, a judging plan and cost tiers. Each idea has a pairing, a watch-out and our verdict, so you can pick one and start today.
What Is Wrong With a Plain List of Halloween Trophy Ideas?
Most lists give you 10 award names and no trophy. They don’t tell you what to build, how to judge or what to hand a child with an allergy.
We split this guide in two. First comes the trophy itself, with materials and steps. Then comes the contest, with categories, fair judging and safety rules.
Which Awards Should You Give?
Pick three to six awards for a small party. More than that and the prizes feel cheap. Mix looks-based awards with funny ones, so everyone has a shot.
| Award | Best for | Judged on |
|---|---|---|
| Scariest Costume | Adults and teens | Fear factor, details |
| Funniest Costume | Any age | Crowd laughs |
| Most Creative | Any age | Original idea, materials |
| Best Homemade | Kids and adults | Craft and effort |
| Best Group or Couple | Pairs and families | Matching theme |
| Best Kid Costume | Under 12 | Fun and effort |
| Crowd Favorite | Everyone | Guest vote |
Our rule: always include a Best Homemade award. It rewards effort over budget.
Trophy Ideas for Costume Contests
1. The Golden Skull Trophy
Glue a plastic skull to a small wood block. Paint it gold and let it dry. Add a brass plate or a paper label with the award name.
Pair with: black ribbon and a candle-lit table.
But watch out: paint fumes need air. Work outside, wear a mask and follow the label.
Our take: our top pick. It looks like a real award, and it costs very little.

2. The Haunted Goblet
Buy a plastic goblet or a thrift-store cup. Paint it black and brush gold on the rim and stem. Drip a little red paint down the bowl for blood.
A life-size plastic skull that becomes the Golden Skull Trophy with a coat of gold paint and a wood base.
Shop NowThis post contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Pair with: a ribbon around the stem.
Watch out: glossy paint stays tacky. Give it a full day to cure.
Our take: a great one for the Scariest Costume. Keep it as decor, and don’t drink from a painted cup.

3. The Golden Pumpkin
Spray a mini pumpkin gold, or use a foam or craft pumpkin. Set it on a round wood slice. Tie a black bow around the stem.
Pair with: a note card with the award name.
Watch out: a real pumpkin rots in a few days. Use a craft pumpkin if the winner keeps it.
Our take: the cutest option for kids. The Golden Pumpkin is also easy to repeat each year.

4. A Witch Hat Cup
Turn a plastic witch hat upside down and fill it with prizes. Wrap the brim with ribbon and attach a paper tag. Set it on a small black plate.
Pair with: a wand and a bag of non-food treats.
But watch out: thin hats tip over. Weight the bottom with a few coins or a rock.
Our take: a good prize that is also a gift bag. It works for the Best Kid Costume.

5. Ribbon Rosettes
Pleat strips of orange, black and purple ribbon into circles. Glue them around a felt circle and add two long tails. Write the award with a gold paint pen.
Pair with: a safety pin on the back.
Watch out: pins and small kids don’t mix. Use a sticker back for little ones.
Our take: the cheapest idea on this list, and the easiest for a big group. You can make 12 in an evening.

Trophy Ideas for Haunted House and Game Contests
6. The Skeleton Hand Trophy
Mount a plastic skeleton hand on a wood base so it reaches up. Paint the bones bronze or gold. Place a small orange ball or mini pumpkin in the palm.
Pair with: a nameplate that reads “Brave Enough.”
Watch out: glue fails on slick plastic. Rough the surface with sandpaper first.
Our take: our favorite for a haunted house challenge. It looks creepy on a mantel after the party.

7. A Mini Cauldron Prize
Fill a small black cauldron with treats, fake spiders and a gift card. Tie a ribbon with the award name on the handle. Set it by the winner’s place.
Pair with: green tissue paper that looks like smoke.
Watch out: candy and allergies. Read the next section on non-food prizes before you fill it.
Our take: a good prize for a game winner, because it works as both trophy and gift.

8. The Bat Medal
Cut a bat shape from black foam or felt. Glue it to a gold circle and string it on ribbon. Stamp or paint the award name on the back.
Pair with: a black ribbon with orange stripes.
Watch out: ribbon around a child’s neck can catch on things. Use a short loop and a breakaway clasp for young kids.
Our take: a medal fits a race or a game better than a statue. It’s also easy to carry home.

9. A Potion Bottle Award
Fill a clear bottle with colored water or sand. Add a cork, a label and a tag with the award name. Wrap a bit of twine around the neck.
Pair with: a small cloth bag.
Watch out: glass breaks. Use a plastic bottle for kids.
Our take: a cute award for the Most Creative. Keep the contents safe and non-edible.

Trophy Ideas for Pumpkin Contests
10. The Golden Pumpkin Plaque
Cut a plank into a simple plaque and paint it black. Add a gold pumpkin cutout and the winner’s category in white paint. Screw a hook on the back.
Pair with: a ribbon for the year.
Watch out: write the year on the back. You will forget it by next October.
Our take: a plaque is the best choice for a yearly neighborhood contest. For ideas to enter, see our pumpkin carving ideas.

11. A Traveling Trophy
Pick one large trophy and pass it to each year’s winner. Add a small brass plate or a paper strip for every winner’s name. Keep the base big enough to hold many names.
Pair with: a shelf in the clubhouse.
Watch out: someone has to keep it. Choose a host before the party ends.
Our take: our favorite for a block party. A trophy with history makes people try harder.

Trophy Ideas for Fun and Inclusive Prizes
12. A Glow-in-the-Dark Award
Paint a small skull or ghost with glow paint and set it on a black base. Charge it under a lamp before the party. Show it off in a dark room.
Pair with: a small flashlight.
Watch out: glow paint fades. Recharge it under light for a few minutes before the reveal.
Our take: a big win for kids. The glow does half the work.

13. A Teal Pumpkin Prize
Fill a teal pumpkin bucket with non-food prizes. Use glow sticks, bubbles, stickers and small toys. Tie a tag on the handle.
Pair with: a sign that says “non-food prizes.”
Watch out: don’t mix food and non-food in one bowl. Keep non-food treats in a separate bowl.
Our take: a kind choice for any party. Non-food prizes cost about the same as candy and you can reuse some of them.

14. Funny Gag Awards
Make a cheap trophy from a plastic cup or a toy and add a silly name. Try Best Dad Joke Mummy or Most Likely to Haunt Your House. Print the label and tape it on.
Pair with: a party hat for the winner.
But watch out: teasing. Keep the names kind, and don’t single out a guest’s looks.
Our take: the best ice breaker at an adult party. For more party ideas, see our Halloween party decoration ideas.

How Do You Judge the Contest Fairly?
Set the rules before the party. Write them on a card and show them at the door. Pick two or three judges who are not entering.
Score each costume from 1 to 5. Judge creativity, effort and fit with the award.
Add a Crowd Favorite vote for guests. Announce the small awards first. Save the big one for last.
Our rule: give each child a small ribbon, so no one leaves empty-handed.
How Do You Keep Costumes Safe?
Costumes and candles are the big risks. The same federal guidance lists flame-resistant fabrics such as nylon or polyester.
It adds reflective tape and masks with big eyeholes. Props should be soft and flexible.
Use flameless candles around the trophy table. Keep the path to the door clear of cords and steps.

What Will It Cost, and How Long Will It Take?
Prices vary by store and region, so use these tiers.
| Tier | What it covers | Typical time |
|---|---|---|
| Free to cheap | Rosettes, gag awards, bat medals | An evening |
| One weekend | Golden skull, goblet, pumpkin, skeleton hand | 1 to 2 days with paint drying |
| Bigger project | Plaques, a traveling trophy, glow awards | A few evenings |
Start with the cheap tier. Add the painted trophies if you host a contest each year.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Skipping the award name. A plain skull is decor. A labeled one is a trophy.
Handing out only candy. Add non-food prizes for kids with allergies.
Judging without rules. Share the criteria first, so no one argues.
Spraying paint indoors. Work outside and follow the can label.
Picking baggy costume props. Choose fitted, flame-resistant pieces with soft props.
FAQ
What are good Halloween trophy ideas? A gold skull, a black goblet, a mini pumpkin and ribbon rosettes are cheap and quick.
What awards should a costume contest have? Scariest, funniest, most creative, best homemade and crowd favorite fit most parties.
How do I make a trophy look real? Use a base, a gold or black finish and a label with the award name.
What non-food prizes can I give? Glow sticks, bubbles, stickers and small toys are common choices.
How many winners should I have? Three to six awards works for most parties. Give every child a small ribbon too.
Related Posts
- Halloween Party Themes for Adults
- Haunted Halloween Party Decorations
- DIY Halloween Yard Decorations

Never miss an update — choose FarmFoodFamily as your preferred source on Google.
How it works: Tap the button below to open Google's settings page, then check the box next to FarmFoodFamily.
Tap the checkbox to turn it blue — that's how you know it's set.
