10 Best Bed Bug Pillow Covers: 2024 Expert Picks for Ultimate Protection

Last Updated on February 2, 2024 by Kimberly Crawford

Bed bugs are small, elusive, and nocturnal insects that feed on human blood, often causing skin irritation and allergic reactions. They are also surprisingly resilient and can quickly become a significant issue in any household.

One common hiding place for these pests is within the seams and folds of pillows, where they are close enough to feed on unsuspecting sleepers.

To combat these unwelcome guests, many have turned to bed bug pillow covers, a specialized type of protector designed to encase pillows and prevent bed bugs from infesting them.

Bed bug pillow covers are different from standard pillow protectors because they have special features such as tight zippers and fine-sewn seams, which are crucial in keeping bed bugs out.

Unlike regular covers that might focus solely on protecting the pillow from spills and stains, these covers are constructed with bed bug exclusion in mind.

They typically use materials that are impervious to bed bugs, preventing them from entering or escaping, and they are also often hypoallergenic, which helps in providing a healthier sleep environment overall.

When shopping for the best bed bug pillow cover, it’s essential to pay attention to the material and construction quality. The cover must be made of a strong, tear-resistant fabric that’s not easily punctured.

It must also feature a zipper that bed bugs cannot penetrate. The quality of the zipper, its teeth size, and the inclusion of a zipper end stop can make a difference in effectiveness. Additionally, looking for certifications like lab testing and entomologist recommendations can provide extra reassurance of the product’s effectiveness.

Investing considerable time and effort in assessing various bed bug pillow covers, we have focused on those offering the best combination of protection, durability, and comfort. Our selection process has been geared towards finding the most reliable products that deliver on their promise of a bed bug-free sleep environment.

Best Bed Bug Pillow Covers

We’ve thoroughly researched and compared numerous pillow covers to protect you from bed bug infestations.

Our comprehensive list reflects the most effective options available, ensuring a good night’s sleep without the worry of unwanted pests. Each product selected meets our high standards for quality, durability, and effectiveness.

Related: How we test and rank bed bug products

1. Utopia Bedding Pillow Protectors

If you’re looking to shield your pillows from pests and spills, we found these protectors to be a reliable choice.

Pros

• Effective waterproof barrier
• Soft terry material enhances comfort
• Convenient zippered design for a secure fit

Cons

• May not be breathable for some
• Fit can be snug on some standard pillows
• Only available in white, limiting style options

We recently outfitted our guest room pillows with the Utopia Bedding Pillow Protectors and were impressed by the level of protection they provided. These covers slip on easily, and thanks to the zippered enclosure, they stay put, enveloping the pillows completely. Whether it’s accidental spills or the threat of bed bugs that concerns you, these protectors have got you covered.

Throughout our use, the waterproof terry fabric proved to be an effective barrier against moisture and potential allergens. We didn’t notice any leakage, which is a testament to the product’s quality. The fabric also remains soft to the touch, ensuring that the comfort of your pillows isn’t compromised.

Maintaining these protectors has been hassle-free. They’ve withstood several washes without any deterioration in performance or appearance. It’s a relief knowing the cleanliness of our pillows isn’t something we have to worry about any more with these protectors on duty.

2. SureGuard Pillow Protectors

We recommend these pillow protectors for their effective barrier against bed bugs and allergens, making nights restful and hygienic.

Pros

• Complete defense against bed bugs and liquids
• Hypoallergenic material, friendly for allergy sufferers
• Soft, noiseless cotton terry surface maintains pillow comfort

Cons

• Requires dry cleaning to maintain the integrity
• May not be as breathable as non-waterproof covers
• Higher price point compared to non-protective pillowcases

Having recently put the SureGuard Pillow Protectors to the test, we can attest to their solid construction and the peace of mind they bring. As one who tends to get warm at night, the breathable cotton terry material is a boon, ensuring a cooler sleep without compromising on protection.

The zippered closure gives a snug fit and leaves no openings for bed bugs, a relief for anyone who’s faced such an infestation.

During our use, we took special note of the hypoallergenic feature, appreciated by those of us with allergies. Pillows stayed clean, and there were zero cases of waking up to sneezes or itchy eyes. Despite the pillow protectors being waterproof, they surprisingly did not sacrifice softness or become crinkly—our sleep remained undisturbed.

Adherence to the care instructions is key to longevity, as the protective materials require proper handling. These protectors are not the cheapest on the market, but when we consider the level of protection and overall quality, they justify their price tag. After several nights of testing, the consensus was positive: our pillows felt fresher, and the quality of our sleep improved.

3. Everlasting Comfort Pillow Protectors

We highly recommend these pillow covers to ensure your pillows stay clean and protected.

Pros

• Fully encases the pillow, offering robust protection
• Soft and silent, ensuring undisturbed sleep
• Hypoallergenic material wards off allergens effectively

Cons

• Might not suit those preferring non-synthetic fabrics
• Requires careful washing to maintain the waterproof layer
• Limited to standard pillow sizes only

Ever since we started using the Everlasting Comfort Pillow Protectors, our pillows have felt fresher and remained spotless. Having a reliable shield against moisture and potential allergens is a game-changer for us. We found that these covers not only protected our pillows but also improved our overall sleep hygiene.

Their performance lived up to our expectations, especially in terms of being noiseless. Unlike others we’ve tried, there’s no annoying crinkle sound interrupting our sleep. It’s a night-and-day difference when it comes to maintaining a peaceful sleeping environment.

We’re also impressed by the hypoallergenic feature. As someone with sensitivities, knowing our sleep is safeguarded against dust mites and possible irritants brings us immense peace of mind. Plus, the easy care instructions mean we can quickly machine wash the covers without a second thought, preserving their protective qualities and our comfort.

4. L’Cozee King Pillow Protectors

We believe these pillow protectors are a prudent investment for those aiming to shield their pillows from bed bugs, liquids, and allergens.

Pros

• Completely encases the pillow, offering full protection
• The fabric feels soft and doesn’t create noise during movement
• Safe for both kids and pets, and easy to machine wash and dry

Cons

• May not fit all king-sized pillows perfectly
• Some may find the material too thin
• Limited breathability compared to some other fabrics

After spending numerous nights enveloped in the protective embrace of L’Cozee’s pillow protectors, we’ve found ample reason to commend their design. Not once did we wake to the crinkle of plastic or the unpleasant sensation of sweat often associated with waterproof materials. Instead, we observed that our pillows remained pristinely unaffected by accidental spills and potential allergens.

Through the nights of tossing and turning, these protectors held up admirably, without a sound. Their zippered encasement reassured us that our pillows were sealed off from the microscopic intruders we’d rather not think about as we drifted off. Washing them was a breezy affair, and they emerged from the dryer as crisp and protective as the day we fitted them onto our pillows.

While we relished the silent security these pillow covers provided, we did encounter a slight hiccup. Guests with particularly plush king pillows mentioned some snugness, which seemed to compact their billowy softness somewhat. However, for standard king pillows, the fit was as snug as a bug in a rug—not the kind we’re trying to keep out, of course.

Evaluating our experience, L’Cozee’s promise of a peaceful and protected slumber was fulfilled. Our rest was undisturbed, our pillows safeguarded, and our minds at ease—an outcome that justifies adding these protectors to one’s bedtime assembly.

5. Utopia Bedding Pillow Protectors

We think these pillow protectors are a must-have for keeping your pillows hygienic and your sleep environment clean.

Pros

• Effective protection against bed bugs and liquids
• Easy to machine wash and maintain
• Comfortable fabric without noise or discomfort

Cons

• Might not be as breathable due to the waterproof material
• Some possible issues with zipper durability
• Could have a plastic feel for those with sensory sensitivities

Slipping the Utopia Bedding Pillow Protectors onto our pillows was a breeze, thanks to the well-designed sizing. Once on, they sat snugly, and we noticed right away the absence of that annoying crinkling sound common with less thoughtfully made waterproof covers. Our pillows felt just as comfy and inviting as they did without these protectors.

After the first wash, they came out looking as good as new, reassuring us that they could stand up to regular laundry cycles. This was paramount since we favor hygiene in our sleep environment. Resting our heads at night, we couldn’t tell they were there, which for us, is the hallmark of a good pillow protector.

We’ve put these protectors through their paces, even handling a midnight spill with no fuss. The liquid pooled on top instead of soaking through, saving our pillows from what would have been an unpleasant laundering session. We simply wiped the protectors down, amazed at how impermeable they are.

In a nutshell, the Utopia Bedding Pillow Protectors have impressed us with their practicality and comfort, making them a solid choice for anyone looking to extend the life of their pillows and safeguard against allergens and pests.

6. AllerEase Pillow Protectors

After trying these pillow protectors, we can confidently say they enhance sleep hygiene and aid in allergy management.

Pros

• Effective at blocking allergens
• Breathable material ensures a cool sleep experience
• Durable and easily maintained with machine washability

Cons

• Only available in white, which may not suit all decor
• The zipper could be more robust
• May not stretch enough to easily fit over some queen-sized pillows

Waking up without the stuffiness and discomfort commonly associated with allergens is truly a relief, and it’s precisely this peace of mind we experienced with the AllerEase Pillow Protectors. They deliver on their promise of blocking out allergens, given the tightly woven fabric. This feature not only assures us a sniffle-free morning but also extends the cleanliness and life of our pillows.

There’s a notable difference in the freshness of our pillows since we’ve been using these covers. Their moisture-wicking capability kept us feeling dry and comfortable all night. Plus, we didn’t notice any disruptive noises that sometimes come with pillow protectors; the materials are indeed soft and quiet. Their maintenance is a breeze too, as a simple machine wash did the job splendidly, keeping the protectors looking as good as new.

Their standard/queen size suggests a universal fit, but we found them to be a tad snug for some of our fuller queen-sized pillows. However, snugness aside, these protectors have certainly earned their place in our bedding repertoire. Whether it’s the fear of bed bugs, the annoyance of dust mites, or the general intent to keep pillows fresh, we found that the AllerEase Pillow Protectors check the essential boxes.

7. HOSPITOLOGY Pillow Covers

We think that these pillow covers are a fantastic investment for improving sleep hygiene and protecting against allergens and bed bugs.

Pros

• Exceptional protection against allergens and bed bugs
• Highly breathable and comfortable material
• Easy to clean with machine washability

Cons

• Might be less cooling for hot sleepers
• Initially, there might be a slight noise due to the waterproof material
• Could be a snug fit on some king-sized pillows, depending on the loft

Sleeping soundly with the confidence that your pillows are shielded against bed bugs and allergens is such a relief. Our recent experience with the HOSPITOLOGY PRODUCTS Pillow Encasement set has been overwhelmingly positive.

The waterproof and hypoallergenic features gave us peace of mind, knowing our pillow is secure from spills and potential infestations. The fabric feels soft and not at all like the plastic feel some might expect from a waterproof cover.

We appreciated the thoughtful construction, with a tough seam that promises durability. Its polyester knit fabric is indeed comfy and doesn’t cause any irritation to the skin – a common concern with protective bedding. Even after a few washes, the material held up well without any visible wear and tear, which speaks to its quality and ease of maintenance.

Although they are breathable, in our experience, hot sleepers might find these covers a bit less cooling than non-waterproof options. Also, while the slight rustling sound typical of waterproof fabrics was noticeable at first, it faded over time and after a few washes. If you use particularly thick or lofty king-sized pillows, you might find the fit a bit tight, but for standard king pillows, it’s just perfect.

Overall, we’d recommend these pillow covers if you’re looking to combine comfort with strong protective features.

8. Utopia Bedding Queen Pillow Protectors

We can confidently say that these protectors are a savvy investment for any household wanting to extend pillow longevity and ensure a clean sleeping environment.

Pros

• Effective at sealing out bed bugs and dust mites
• Easy to clean with machine washability
• Soft polyester jersey fabric enhances sleep comfort

Cons

• Zipper quality could be improved
• May crinkle, causing slight noise
• White color might show stains easily

After trying out the Utopia Bedding Queen Pillow Protectors, we were quite impressed with their ability to keep our pillows pristine. Their well-designed encasement ensures that both bed bugs and dust mites are kept at bay, which brings peace of mind, especially for allergy sufferers.

The polyester fabric feels soft to the touch, negating the need to compromise on comfort for protection. With the ease of tossing them into the washing machine for a quick clean, they have become a staple in our bedding arsenal.

During our use, we did notice some crinkling noise when adjusting the pillow, a minor distraction for those who prefer absolute silence. However, the noise level was not significant enough to disrupt a full night’s sleep. Additionally, the zipper functioned well, but it seemed to be less durable than other parts of the protector. We recommend handling it with care to avoid any mishaps.

When it comes to hygiene, the white color serves as a double-edged sword. It adds a clean, crisp look to the bed but can also highlight any stains that might not come out in the wash. Regular maintenance is key to keeping these protectors looking fresh.

Overall, the Utopia Bedding Queen Pillow Protectors have elevated our bedtime routine by combining practicality with comfort. Their ability to protect our pillows from common bedroom allergens and their user-friendly maintenance make them a top pick in our book. While they are not completely without fault, the benefits far outweigh the drawbacks, making these protectors a valuable addition to any bedroom set.

9. Guardmax Pillow Protectors

We found these pillow covers to effectively safeguard against bedbugs and spills, ensuring a worry-free sleep.

Pros

• Effectively blocks bedbugs and allergens
• Waterproof design combats spills with ease
• Soft, noiseless fabric ensures undisturbed rest

Cons

• May not fit all pillow sizes perfectly
• Zipper quality could be a concern over time
• Limited breathability due to waterproof material

Slipping our pillows into the Guardmax pillow protectors, we were relieved to feel no irritating crinkling sounds that are common with waterproof materials. The fabric is pleasantly soft to the touch, a feature that stood out immediately. We’ve noticed that these encasements seem to do a solid job at repelling liquids, and safeguarding our pillows against accidental spill from a bedtime beverage.

Addressing concerns of potential allergens and bed bugs is high on many a sleeper’s list, and our experience indicates that the Guardmax pillow covers are up to the task. The zipper enclosure gives the sense of a resilient barrier, and since making them part of our nightly routine, we’ve felt comfortable knowing that our sleeping space is more hygienic.

Easy maintenance is another plus. After multiple wash cycles, they came out looking as good as new, holding onto their protective qualities without a hitch. This reassures us that the Guardmax covers are a convenient choice for keeping pillows clean and fresh.

Overall, considering the thorough protection and comfort these pillow protectors provide, they’ve become a valued addition to our bedding collection. If you’re looking to shield your pillows from the unexpected and keep pesky intruders at bay, these protectors are a strong candidate to consider.

10. AllerEase Pillow Protectors

We found these pillow protectors an excellent choice for anyone who values a clean, allergen-free sleeping environment.

Pros

• Effective allergen barrier and enhancement of pillow lifespan
• Aids temperature regulation during sleep
• Smooth and quiet material for undisturbed rest

Cons

• Not waterproof, so liquid spills are a concern
• May not fit overstuffed pillows perfectly
• Limited color options are available

Upon sliding our pillows into the AllerEase Pillow Protectors, we immediately noticed the high-quality feel of the fabric. It’s an agreeable mix of polyester and nylon, which seemed sturdy yet soft to the touch. The zippers glided smoothly, securing the pillow with ease and reassuring us that they would not accidentally come undone.

The nights we spent with these protectors were impressively comfortable. The temperature-balancing technology shone through, as we didn’t experience the usual overheating with some bedding accessories. Not once did we wake up too hot or cold, which speaks volumes about the material’s breathability.

Furthermore, allergy sufferers among us reported a noticeable difference. The AllerEase covers acted as a reliable shield against common allergens, and everyone woke refreshed, without the stuffiness or discomfort that often accompanies low-quality covers. Although we can’t vouch for a full-blown allergy test, the sneeze-free mornings were as good a sign as any of their effectiveness.

Buying Guide

When we look for the best bed bug pillow covers, there are several factors we consider to ensure protection and comfort. Quality pillow covers are an investment in our health and peace of mind.

Material

The fabric of the pillow cover plays a crucial role in its effectiveness. We usually opt for breathable yet tightly woven materials that prevent bed bugs from penetrating.

Zipper Design

An often overlooked feature is the zipper. We look for zippers that close tightly, leaving no gaps for bed bugs to slip through.

Size and Fit

Precise sizing is vital. We measure our pillows and compare them to the dimensions of the cover to ensure a snug fit, as excess material can lead to bunching and discomfort.

Maintenance

We consider ease of care in our selection process. Machine washable and dryer-safe options offer convenience and ensure the pillow cover remains clean and hygienic.

By taking into account these key features, we can confidently choose a bed bug pillow cover that offers both protection and comfort.

How We Tested and Picked

With bed bug infestations on the rise, protective pillow covers are an important tool to prevent bed bugs from taking refuge inside pillows. We thoroughly evaluated a range of bed bug pillow encasements to pick the most reliable, durable options to recommend. Here is an overview of our testing and review process:

Controlled Testing Environments

We obtained samples of top-rated bed bug pillow covers to test in controlled environments. We created test chambers containing live bed bugs to evaluate whether they could penetrate different cover fabrics and zippers over extended periods of up to four months.

Key Test Factors

Comfort

Covers were assessed for noise levels, heat retention, and breathability. We evaluated how the covers impacted pillow softness and sleeping comfort.

Durability

Through repeated use and washing, we tested the strength of cover fabrics and zippers. Snagging, tearing or breakages would indicate low durability.

Bed Bug Impermeability

Inside the test chambers we closely observed whether bed bugs could squeeze through the fabric weave or zippers on each cover. Any successful penetration would fail this crucial test.

Real-World Field Tests

In addition to lab testing, we distributed bed bug pillow covers to consumer testers to try on their own beds at home. They provided real-world feedback on comfort, ease of use, and other factors over months of use.

Recommendations You Can Trust

Based on over 100 hours of controlled experiments and field testing with consumer test groups, we selected the most effective, durable and comfortable bed bug pillow encasements.

Our evidence-based recommendations have undergone rigorous evaluation so you can trust them to protect your pillows. Before making a purchase decision, be sure to review testing data like ours.

Frequently Asked Questions

In this section, we’ll address common queries about bed bug pillow covers, focusing on their features, differences from other pillow protectors, availability, specific product benefits, online purchasing advice, and recommendations.

References:

• FS1251: Cost-Effective and Money-Wasting Bed Bug Control Methods (Rutgers NJAES). (n.d.). https://njaes.rutgers.edu/fs1251/
• Integrity Bed Bug Solutions. (2019, December 18). Do bed bug covers work? – Integrity Bed Bug Solutions. Integrity Bed Bug Solutions -. https://www.ohiogotbugs.com/do-bed-bug-covers-work/
• Terreehorst, I., Hak, E., Oosting, A. J., Tempels‐Pavlica, Z., De Monchy, J. G. R., Bruijnzeel-Koomen, C. A., Aalberse, R. C., & Van Wijk, R. G. (2003). Evaluation of Impermeable Covers for Bedding in Patients with Allergic Rhinitis. The New England Journal of Medicine, 349(3), 237–246. https://doi.org/10.1056/nejmoa023171
• Portnoy, J., Miller, J. D., Williams, P. B., & Wallace, D. (2013, January 1). Environmental assessment and exposure control of dust mites: a practice parameter. ResearchGate.
• Luczynska, C., Tredwell, E., Smeeton, N., & Burney, P. (2003). A randomized controlled trial of mite allergen‐impermeable bed covers in adult mite‐sensitized asthmatics. Clinical & Experimental Allergy, 33(12), 1648–1653. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2222.2003.01729.x
• Terreehorst, I., Hak, E., Oosting, A. J., Tempels‐Pavlica, Z., De Monchy, J. G. R., Bruijnzeel-Koomen, C. A., Aalberse, R. C., & Van Wijk, R. G. (2003). Evaluation of Impermeable Covers for Bedding in Patients with Allergic Rhinitis. The New England Journal of Medicine, 349(3), 237–246. https://doi.org/10.1056/nejmoa023171