American Craftsman Windows Review (2024): Unbiased Expert Analysis

Last Updated on February 2, 2024 by Kimberly Crawford

When considering home improvements, the quality of replacement windows is paramount. American Craftsman, a notable brand in the vinyl window market, offers a variety of options that could suit your needs.

Known for their accessible pricing and widespread availability, these windows cater to those looking for a balance between performance and budget. Assessing the American Craftsman window reviews can provide valuable insight into their real-world functionality and value.

Selecting the right windows for your home involves examining factors like material quality, energy efficiency, and aesthetic appeal. American Craftsman windows are designed to meet diverse demands, whether you’re seeking better insulation or a fresh look for your home.

Customer feedback and third-party performance metrics are practical resources for understanding how these windows stand up to everyday use and how they compare with other brands in the market.

In this article

american craftsman windows review expert

Key Takeaways

  • American Craftsman offers a range of vinyl replacement windows balancing cost and performance.
  • Energy efficiency and customer satisfaction are critical elements of the brand’s reputation.
  • The brand presents a variety of styles and functionalities to align with different homeowner preferences.

American Craftsman Brand Overview

When considering American Craftsman for your window needs, you’re looking at a brand with a storied history, a strong market position, and a strategic relationship with Andersen, one of the industry’s juggernauts.


American Craftsman started as an independent window manufacturer but has since become a part of the larger Andersen family. This transition marks a significant evolution from a standalone brand to one that benefits from the expertise and resources of a much larger entity.

Market Position

American Craftsman is recognized for offering affordable and reliable window options. Positioned as a cost-effective choice, these windows appeal to you if you seek a balance between quality and value. Widely available at home improvement stores, American Craftsman products cater mainly to the DIY market and renovation projects.

American Craftsman and Andersen Relationship

In acquiring American Craftsman, Andersen has expanded its market reach, appealing to a wider audience.

You benefit from this relationship through access to a synergy of Andersen’s technological innovations and the budget-friendly offerings of American Craftsman.

The windows produced under this partnership aim to combine quality with economy, accommodating the preferences of a diverse customer base.

Product Line-Up

american crafts window product lines

In selecting the right windows for your home, it’s essential to understand the differences in the product lines offered by American Craftsman. Your choice will largely depend on the specific features you’re looking for, such as durability, style, and insulation properties.

American Craftsman 70 Series

The American Craftsman 70 Series is designed with premium vinyl construction, offering a higher degree of structural integrity and durability. This series includes casement, awning, and double-hung windows, providing a range of options for your ventilation and aesthetic needs. The 70 series windows feature thicker vinyl frames compared to the lower-end series, enhancing overall performance.

American Craftsman 50 Series

Your other option within the brand is the American Craftsman 50 Series, a more economical alternative that doesn’t compromise on quality. This series features vinyl windows in popular styles like single hung and double-hung, allowing for versatility in various settings.

While the 50 series may offer more basic features compared to the 70, it still delivers reliable function and a clean appearance suitable for many homes.

Other Offerings

Beyond the 70 and 50 series, American Craftsman may provide additional options to meet diverse needs, such as hopper windows, ideal for basements or tight spaces requiring ventilation.

Each window type across its offerings is crafted to meet certain aesthetic and functional requirements, ensuring you find a suitable match for your specific preferences and home design.

Material Quality and Construction

When selecting windows for your home, the material quality and construction are crucial factors. These elements determine the longevity, energy efficiency, and aesthetic appeal of the windows. Let’s examine the specifics of American Craftsman windows to understand what you’re investing in.

Vinyl Material Benefits

The vinyl used in American Craftsman windows offers several advantages. Primarily, it’s known for its energy efficiency due to the material’s natural insulation properties.

Vinyl is also low maintenance, as it doesn’t require painting or staining. Moreover, it’s resistant to corrosion and decay, ensuring your windows remain in optimal condition for longer.

  • Resistant to environmental factors
  • Retains insulative properties over time

Glass and Insulation Features

The glass in American Craftsman windows typically incorporates Low-E coating and may be filled with argon gas to enhance thermal performance. Low-E, or low-emissivity, refers to a thin coating that reflects heat while allowing light to pass through. Argon gas is an inert, non-toxic gas used between panes for added insulation.

  • Low-E glass maximizes heat reflection
  • Argon gas enhances insulation

Durability and Design Aspects

Your focus on durability will be rewarded with American Craftsman’s robust construction. The windows’ durable design is built to withstand various weather conditions without compromising on visual design.

They offer a range of designs that suit different architectural styles, making it easier to match the windows with your home’s aesthetic.

  • Built to endure diverse climates
  • Variety of styles for personalized aesthetics

Energy Efficiency and Performance

When looking for replacement windows, your top considerations likely include how well they prevent heat transfer and their overall energy efficiency.

American Craftsman windows have specific features designed to enhance their energy performance and can potentially reduce your heating and cooling costs.

Low-E Glass

American Craftsman windows use Low-E (low-emissivity) glass, which has a microscopically thin coating that reflects infrared energy (heat) while allowing visible light to pass through. This means during the summer, the heat is reflected away from your home, and in the winter, interior heat is retained. These windows offer various options for Low-E coatings, each providing different levels of energy efficiency and UV protection.

Energy Star Ratings

Many American Craftsman windows are Energy Star rated, which indicates they meet or exceed federal guidelines for energy efficiency.

By choosing Energy Star-rated windows, you can be confident that your windows will contribute to lower energy bills and greater comfort inside your home.

Insulative Properties

To enhance their insulative properties, American Craftsman windows may include options such as triple-pane glass and the use of inert gases like argon between panes.

The triple-pane glass provides an extra layer of insulation, significantly reducing thermal transfer. This is often combined with argon gas, which is denser than air, to reduce the amount of heat that passes through the window assembly, boosting the windows’ overall thermal performance.

Installation and Replacement Process

When considering American Craftsman windows, you must understand the nuances of both the installation for new construction and the replacement of existing windows.

Whether you’re constructing a new home or upgrading your current residence, the installation process is critical to ensuring performance and longevity.

New Construction Installation

For new construction, your windows play a crucial role from the foundation of your home’s design. American Craftsman windows must be installed following precise framing specifications. You should ensure that:

  • The rough opening is square, level, and the correct size.
  • The waterproofing and flashing are adequately applied to prevent moisture intrusion.

Careful adherence to these practices will safeguard the integrity of your windows from the very start.

Replacement Window Installation

When replacing existing windows, assessing the condition of the frame and sills is essential. With American Craftsman windows, you have the option to choose insert installation or full-frame replacement. Here are the key steps:

  1. Measure your existing window openings accurately for a proper fit.
  2. Remove the old window, taking care to avoid damage to the surrounding wall.
  3. Install the new window, ensuring it is plumb, level, and square.
  4. Seal the window with appropriate insulation and caulking for energy efficiency.

Take note that proper installation of replacement windows can improve energy savings and reduce drafts.

Installation Support

American Craftsman provides installation guidance which can be invaluable for both DIY enthusiasts and professional installers. Remember:

  • Follow the detailed installation instructions provided by American Craftsman.
  • Review online resources such as step-by-step guides to familiarize yourself with the process.
  • Utilize customer service lines for direct assistance if you encounter issues.

Proper installation is key to ensuring that your windows are durable, functional, and aesthetically pleasing.

Pricing and Value

When considering American Craftsman windows, it’s essential to balance cost-effectiveness with quality to determine the value you’re receiving.

Cost Analysis

American Craftsman windows are positioned as budget-friendly options, with their 50 Series being the most economical.

Pricing is tiered, with the cost generally increasing from the 50 Series to the 70 and 5900 Series. To put it in perspective, you might find the 50 Series is about a 1 on a 5 point scale where 1 signifies the lowest price range.

Price Comparison with Other Brands

In a direct price comparison, other brands like Pella and Jeld-Wen offer product lines that can be more expensive, reflecting their market positioning as premium options.

In contrast, Ply Gem windows cater to a similar cost-conscious segment but may vary in price due to different product features or quality levels. You need to compare the costs and features side by side, considering elements such as energy efficiency, durability, and warranty.

Warranty and Customer Service

When selecting American Craftsman windows, you’ll appreciate the assurance that comes with comprehensive warranty terms and dedicated customer service support.

Warranty Terms

American Craftsman offers a Limited Lifetime Warranty for their window products, specifically for the 50, 60, and 70 series windows and patio doors.

This warranty is designed to give you peace of mind, as it covers various components against material and workmanship defects for the lifetime of the original purchaser while installed in the original residence. For precise coverage details, check the American Craftsman Warranty document.

Customer Service Experience

The customer service experience for American Craftsman windows aims to be responsive and helpful, addressing any concerns or questions that may arise. Past reviews suggest that experiences can vary, but there are positive accounts of warranty claims being handled efficiently.

If you experience any issues, it is recommended to contact their service department promptly for potential resolutions. For insights from other homeowners, you might refer to forum discussions such as those found on AnandTech.

Consumer Feedback

american craftsman consumer feedback

When considering American Craftsman windows, your decision should be informed by reliable consumer feedback. This ensures you understand both the benefits and potential issues as reported by credible sources and actual homeowners.

Consumer Reports Insight

According to Consumer Reports, ratings for American Craftsman windows reflect how these products perform in wind- and rain-resistance tests. These ratings are generated from rigorous, unbiased testing to help you make a well-informed choice.

Homeowner Reviews and Testimonials

On forums and review websites, homeowner reviews often discuss satisfaction levels and any complaints regarding American Craftsman windows. A testimonial by a user on Viewpoints mentions issues such as having to replace the window frequently, indicating some customers have faced significant issues post-installation.

It’s crucial to weigh these testimonials as they can provide you with a practical understanding of what to expect.

Performance Metrics

american craftsman performance metrics

When evaluating the performance of American Craftsman windows, focus on their ability to retain air and resist water ingress. These factors are critical to the longevity and efficiency of your windows.

Air Leakage Ratings

Air leakage, measured in cubic feet per minute per square foot of window area (cfm/ft²), gauges how well windows prevent air infiltration. For American Craftsman windows, specifically in the 50 and 70 series, the models come with varied ratings. Look for lower numbers, as they signify better performance. For instance:

  • 50 Series: Typically, these may have higher air leakage ratings, suggesting potential for greater air infiltration.
  • 70 Series: These are likely to have lower air leakage ratings, indicating a tighter seal against air leakage.

Rain Resistance Test

Rain resistance in windows is tested through standardized methods that simulate wind-driven rainstorms. These tests help determine how well the window can keep moisture out.

  • American Craftsman’s ratings: Seek models that meet or exceed ASTM water penetration standards. For example, the 70 series windows are described to have superior insulation and, by implication, may offer better rain resistance.
  • Testing results: Pay attention to ratings like Design Pressure (DP) ratings, which include water penetration benchmarks. A higher DP rating suggests better rain resistance.

By scrutinizing these metrics closely, you ensure that your selected windows will perform effectively against the elements.

Aesthetic Options

american craftsman aesthetics

When choosing windows for your home, aesthetics play a significant role in complementing your home’s character. American Craftsman windows offer a variety of aesthetic options to match your personal style and home’s architectural design.

Color Variations

You can select from multiple color choices, particularly classic white, which remains a popular choice for its timeless appeal and ease of integrating with most home exteriors.

The color variations ensure that you can find the right match to either coordinate with your existing palette or create a new color scheme for a home renovation.

Window Styles

American Craftsman windows come in a range of styles that can satisfy both traditional and contemporary design preferences. Here’s a brief look at the styles you can choose from:

  • Double-Hung Windows: These are a versatile choice that works with various architectural styles.
  • Casement Windows: Perfect for you if you prefer a modern look with a functional design.
  • Sliding Windows: These work well if you are looking for a space-saving option without compromising on aesthetics.

Each window style contributes to the overall appearance and design of your home, and with American Craftsman, you’ll find options to enhance your home’s beauty and reflect your personal taste.

Brand Comparisons

When considering replacement windows, comparing American Craftsman with other leading brands is crucial to make an informed decision. You’ll find detailed distinctions and features based on performance, types, and other criteria.

American Craftsman vs. Jeld-Wen

American Craftsman windows are known for their affordable vinyl options, offering a balance between quality and value. On the other hand, Jeld-Wen windows have a range of styles, including both vinyl and wood options, giving you more variety to choose from. Below is a comparison:

CriteriaAmerican CraftsmanJeld-Wen
Material OptionsPrimarily vinylVinyl, wood, and others
StylesCasement, double-hung, sliderExtensive line of casement, double-hung, etc.
Price PointGenerally more budget-friendlyVaries, including higher-end options

For more on Jeld-Wen’s product offerings, explore this detailed comparison at Ralph’s Way.

American Craftsman vs. Pella

Comparing American Craftsman with Pella, you’ll notice that Pella often stands out in the realm of innovation and design. Pella offers a wider range of material choices including wood, fiberglass, and vinyl, catering to different aesthetic and functional demands.

CriteriaAmerican CraftsmanPella
Material OptionsMainly vinylWood, fiberglass, vinyl
Energy EfficiencyGoodVery good to excellent
CustomizationLimitedExtensive customization options
WarrantyLimited Lifetime WarrantyUp to Limited Lifetime Warranty

American Craftsman vs. Andersen

Lastly, when you compare American Craftsman to Andersen Windows, the latter is typically regarded for its higher-end offerings in terms of durability and customization. Andersen’s portfolio includes a variety of options that can be tailored to your home’s architectural style.

CriteriaAmerican CraftsmanAndersen Windows
Material QualityBuilder-gradeHigher-end, multiple material options
DurabilitySatisfactoryKnown for long-lasting performance
Price RangeMore affordableGenerally higher-priced
WarrantyLimitedTransferrable warranties available

For an in-depth guide to their differences, inspect this comprehensive resource at The House of Figs.

Potential Issues and Considerations

When choosing American Craftsman Windows, you should be aware of potential issues that might require attention post-installation. From common defects that can arise to handling drafty windows, it’s crucial to understand the ins and outs to ensure longevity and performance.

Common Defects and Repairs

American Craftsman windows sometimes exhibit loose components or operational difficulties. For example, if your window won’t stay open, this may signal a problem with the sash balance. Replacing the sash balance is a standard repair. Additionally, sashes that feel loose require immediate attention as they can affect the window’s seal and integrity.

You may encounter issues with window tabs, which are meant to limit how far a window can open. If these are not functioning properly, they will need to be repositioned or replaced. Routine checks and maintenance can prevent small defects from becoming larger issues.

Handling Drafty Windows

If your windows feel drafty, it may be a sign of seal failure or improper installation. To address this:

  • Check the seals around your windows for any signs of damage or wear.
  • Inspect the weatherstripping for gaps or deterioration and replace if necessary.

An effective fix for drafty windows is to apply caulk around the window frame, both inside and out, ensuring a tighter seal. In some instances, professional realignment or adjustment of your windows may be required to eliminate drafts and improve insulation.

Frequently Asked Questions

In this section, you’ll find targeted answers to common inquiries regarding American Craftsman windows, their features, durability, and comparison with other brands.

How do American Craftsman windows compare to Pella in terms of quality and price?

American Craftsman windows are often recognized for their budget-friendly pricing, positioning them as a cost-effective option compared to brands like Pella. While Pella is known for higher-end products, American Craftsman provides a range of quality suitable for varied needs and budgets.

What distinguishes the American Craftsman 50 series from the 70 series windows?

The American Craftsman 50 series windows are designed as builder-grade, offering an affordable vinyl option, while the 70 series includes upgraded features and enhanced architectural styling for better performance and aesthetics.

Can you provide insights on the durability and customer satisfaction from Consumer Reports on American Craftsman windows?

Detailed reviews on customer satisfaction and the durability of American Craftsman windows are available, but specific data from Consumer Reports requires a subscription. Online feedback suggests varied experiences with the brand’s durability and customer service.

Are American Craftsman windows effective for impact resistance in severe weather areas?

American Craftsman windows offer standard durability and protection against weather elements. For severe weather areas prone to high-impact events, specialized impact-resistant windows should be considered.

What options are available for mulled window configurations with American Craftsman windows?

American Craftsman windows offer different options for mulled window configurations, allowing homeowners to customize the look and functionality of their window installations to suit their architectural preferences.

How does American Craftsman’s partnership with Andersen reflect on the quality of their products?

The partnership aligns American Craftsman with Andersen’s reputation for quality, suggesting a commitment to manufacturing standards and customer service influenced by Andersen’s well-established brand presence in the window industry.


  • Wade, R., & Wade, R. (2023, October 24). American Craftsman 50 vs. 70 series Windows for home. Ralph’s Way.
  • Energy Performance ratings for windows, doors, and skylights. (n.d.).
  • Jaime. (2024, January 9). Replacing your American Craftsman window: A Step-by-Step Guide | Learn Glass Blowing.
  • American Craftsman Warranty – Ply Gem. (2023, October 3). Ply Gem.
  • Bbhaag. (2018, September 19). [Updated]American Craftsman windows by Andersen warranty claim. A positive review [Online forum post]. AnandTech Forums: Technology, Hardware, Software, and Deals.
  • Stanger, T. (2019, March 1). Best Replacement Windows of 2023. Consumer Reports.
  • American Craftsman Windows reviews – (n.d.).