The 28 Worst and Best Window Brands: A 2024 Comparison Guide

There are many reasons to choose Marvin Windows, but here are just a few:

– They’re made in the USA with high-quality materials and craftsmanship.

– Their design options are endless, so you can find the perfect window for your home.

– They’re Energy Star certified, meaning they’ll help keep your home comfortable and save you money on your energy bills.

1.4 Milgard Windows 

• Average selling price:  $300–$600
• Rating:4.5/5
• Customer Review: “We know the Milgard brand and decided it was a good choice for us. The windows are fantastic! We face East and West, so get a lot of sun and heat! These windows do cut the amount of heat coming in, which is a big help with the intense heat we have been having”- Memory Customer

There are a few reasons why Milgard Windows is the best window brand. One reason is that they have been in business for over 50 years and have a lot of experience making windows.

Another reason is that they offer a variety of window styles to choose from, so you can find the perfect style for your home. Lastly, Milgard windows are made with high-quality materials, so you can be sure they will last for years.

1.5 Alside Windows 

• Average selling price: $550-$2000
• Rating:3.5/5
• Customer Review: Positive customer reviews often highlighted the easy installation, the quality of the windows, and their happiness with the overall service and experience. 

Alside Windows has been manufacturing windows and siding since 1947. They are one of the oldest and most reliable window brands available.

Alside Windows is known for its quality control and customer service. They have a wide variety of window styles to choose from, and all of their windows come with a lifetime warranty covering defects in materials and workmanship.

If you’re looking for a reliable window brand with a long history, Alside Windows is a great choice.

1.6 Cascade Windows 

• Average selling price: $500- $2000
• Rating: 4/5
• Customer Review: “Bought Cascade windows through Lowes. I was initially skeptical because I had not heard of this brand before. I selected what I thought looked brownish, the rep told me it was olive. It turns out I love it more than I thought would.”- Nattie M

Cascade Windows is another great option for the best window replacement brand. They offer a wide variety of styles and colors to choose from, so you can find the perfect windows for your home. Cascade Windows is also Energy Star certified, so you’ll know that they’ll help save you money on your energy bills.

1.7 Certainteed 

• Average selling price: $350-$2600
• Rating:3.8/5
• Customer Review: “The installation went great and was done by a local contractor with lots of experience with these exact windows. He was precise and neat and didn’t cut corners with the installation. He trimmed and primed all the interiors and did all the caulking and touch-ups very well…..”- Steve – Homeowner – from New Jersey in 2010

The company has been making quality products for over a hundred years. They have a wide variety of products to choose from, so you can find the perfect one for your home.

Their products are affordable and will last for many years. They offer a lifetime warranty on all their windows.

1.8 Pella 

• Average selling price: $400–$2,000
• Rating:4/5
• Customer Review: “We purchased 18 Pella 250 series windows. They are made with very good glass and are big and bright. We know that Pella is a good brand, and they live up to their reputation. The frames are well made, and they are well insulated.” —Lisa H. via Best Company

Pella Corporation is a good brand because they have been in business for over 80 years and they specialize in windows, doors, and sunrooms. They also have a wide variety of products to choose from, which makes them a great option for any home improvement project. Plus, their customer service is top-notch, so you can rest assured that you’re in good hands.

1.9 Weather Shield 

• Average selling price: $550-$1500
• Rating: 4/5
• Customer Review: Weather Shield shines thanks to its affordable price points and low-maintenance extruded aluminum-clad wood windows. 

There are several reasons why Weather Shield Windows And Doors is one of the best window replacement brands. First, the company has been in business for over 60 years and has a reputation for quality products.

Second, Weather Shield windows are energy-efficient and can help save money on your energy bills.

Third, the company offers a wide variety of window styles to choose from, so you can find the perfect window for your home.

Finally, Weather Shield windows are backed by a lifetime warranty, so you can be confident that you’re making a good investment. If you’re looking for quality windows and doors, Weather Shield is a brand to consider.

1.10 Kolbe Windows and Doors

• Average selling price: $550-$1000
• Rating: 3.8/5.0
• Customer Review: “We installed Kolbe Ultra French By-pass doors and casement. Also a patio door replacement for the front door. We love the look!–we sprung for Vertical grain fir on the inside….. We are just super satisfied!”- Stu and Carolyn Rockafellow

Kolbe Windows and Doors boasts a legacy spanning more than 75 years. Over this extensive period, the company has curated a vast array of window styles, presenting customers with over 50 color options. Furthermore, their replacement windows stand out for their customization options, being offered in vinyl, aluminum-clad, and wood materials.

In addition to their diverse product range, Kolbe actively collaborates with architects and designers, ensuring that their offerings remain in tune with evolving consumer preferences.

The company takes pride in delivering windows and doors of exceptional quality, maintaining affordability in certain options. However, this brand warranty is variable following products, ranging from 5 to 30 years. Also, single-hung options are unavailable for Kolbe Windows.

1.11 Woodgrain Millwork 

• Average selling price: $400-800
• Rating:3.7/5
• Customer Review: Woodgrain Doors can be configured in a huge variety of designs and glass options, meaning every homeowner’s Woodgrain door can be a unique reflection of his or her personality

Woodgrain Millwork is one of the best window brands due to the wide variety of products to choose from, and high quality. They also offer excellent customer service, so you can be sure that you’re getting the best product possible. Plus, their prices are very competitive, which makes them a great option for anyone looking for new windows or doors.

1.12 PGT Custom Windows & Doors

• Average selling price: $700-$1300
• Rating: 4.3/5
• Customer Review: Customers were pleased with the windows’ quality and had positive experiences with their local dealers. Some customers noted that the impact-resistant windows provided solid protection during hurricane conditions

PGT Windows offers an appealing and dependable array of impact-resistant products designed to protect families. PGT Windows holds the highest number of Miami-Dade certifications in the industry, underscoring its reputation for producing top-tier windows and doors tailored for adverse weather conditions.

This expertise is the foundation of the brand’s stellar reputation in crafting hurricane-resistant, impact-resistant, and energy-efficient vinyl and aluminum windows. For those seeking standard yet stylish options, PGT Windows also manufactures non-impact products, demonstrating its commitment to catering to a diverse range of customer needs.

1.13 Loewen Windows 

• Average selling price: $850-$1.199
• Rating:3.7/5
• Customer Review: Loewen offers specialized luxury window materials, artisan and custom designs, and a long-held history as a reputable window provider. 

There are many reasons to choose Loewen Windows. They offer a wide range of window styles and options, so you can find the perfect windows for your home.

Their windows are made with high-quality materials and construction techniques, so they will last for years. Plus, their customer service is top-notch, so you can be sure you’re getting the best possible product and service.

1.14 New South Window Solutions 

• Average selling price: $8000 – $12,000
• Rating:4.6/5
• Customer Review: “I’d recommend NewSouth Window highly and I’ve always done that. I went with them because of their pricing and reviews online. I bought impact windows and doors and it’s the best…”- Palm City, FL

The New South Window Solutions team has been in the window industry for over 25 years. They know their products and they care about customer satisfaction. That’s why they offer a lifetime warranty on all of their windows – so you can be sure that you’re getting a quality product.

Plus, New South Window Solutions is a family-owned and operated business, so you can trust them to put your needs first.

1.15  Earthwise Group LLC 

• Average selling price: $500-$1500
• Rating:4.5/5
• Customer Review: “We saw lower energy bills and a reduction in outside noise right away. We’re very happy with our Earthwise windows!” – Mark R.

Well, first of all, they’re a green company. They use recycled materials in their products and they are always looking for ways to reduce their environmental impact.

They’re also a very customer-focused company. They offer a lot of customization options for their windows and they work with customers to make sure that they’re getting exactly what they want.

Finally, they’re just a well-made product. Their windows are beautiful and they’re built to last. I’ve never had any problems with them and I know that I can count on them to keep my home looking great for years to come.

1.16  Harvey Windows 

• Average selling price: $500-$1350
• Rating: 4.3/5
• Customer Review: Most customers praised the company’s quality products and excellent customer service. 

Harvey Windows is the best window replacement brand because it offers quality products that are backed by a solid warranty.

The company has been in business for over 60 years and is committed to providing customers with the best possible experience.

Harvey Windows also offers a wide variety of styles and options to choose from, so you can find the perfect windows for your home.

1.17 Okna Windows 

• Average selling price: $750-$900
• Rating: 4.1/5
• Customer Review: “Great window manufacturer who stands behind their product. Replaced 30+ windows in the entire house and a patio door  8 years ago….”– Mike M., Illinois

Okna windows are a good brand because they are energy efficient. They have a good reputation and they are affordable. Okna windows are also easy to install and come with a warranty.

I would recommend Okna Windows to anyone who is looking for new windows for their home. They are a great investment and will help you save money on your energy bills.

1.18 Ply Gem Windows 

• Average selling price: $350-$1500
• Rating: 4/5
• Customer Review: “Best vinyl windows made and a great warranty.” —Steve Watt 

Ply Gem windows are a good brand because they offer a variety of window types and styles to choose from. They also have a wide range of prices, so you can find a window that fits your budget.

Ply Gem windows are also energy efficient, which can save you money on your energy bills. And finally, Ply Gem windows are made with quality materials, so they are durable and long-lasting. If you’re looking for a new window, Ply Gem is a good brand to consider.

1.19 Polaris Windows 

• Average selling price: $550-$950
• Rating: 4.5/5
• Customer Review: “I love my Polaris windows. It is better than Andersen windows were leaky 25-year-old window casements. I want my whole house to have Polaris windows. Maybe this summer.” Roxanne M Hardy

Polaris Windows & Doors Inc. is a good brand because they have been in the business for many years and they are known for their high-quality products. Their windows are made with durable materials that can withstand extreme weather conditions, so you can be sure that your home will be well protected.

In addition, Polaris Windows & Doors Inc. offers a wide variety of window styles and options, so you can find the perfect windows for your home. Plus, their customer service is top-notch, so you can rest assured that you will be taken care of throughout the entire process.

Polaris Windows & Doors Inc. are known for their high-quality products

1.20 Simonton Windows 

• Average selling price: $200–$1500
• Rating: 3.4/5
• Customer Review: Customers complimented the energy efficiency of the windows, claiming their energy bills were reduced once they were in place.

Simonton Windows has been in business since 1946 and is one of the most well-known window brands.

Simonton windows are known for their energy efficiency and durability. They offer a wide range of window styles and options to choose from, so you can find the perfect windows for your home.

Simonton Windows is also backed by a lifetime limited warranty, which is one of the best in the industry.

Simonton Windows is backed by a lifetime limited warranty

2. How can you recognize a window brand that may not be good?

The best way to identify a bad window brand is to research online. There are many websites and forums where people post their experiences with different brands of windows. Another way to identify a bad window brand is to ask around.

Talk to your friends, family, and neighbors about their experiences with different brands of windows. Finally, you can consult with a window professional to get their opinion on different brands of windows.

There are a few telltale signs that can help you identify a bad window brand. Here are some of the most common ones:

• The windows are made with low-quality materials.
• The windows are not Energy Star certified.
• The company needs a better reputation.
• The warranty could be better.
• The windows are difficult to install.

A telltale sign identifies a bad window brand is not Energy Star certified

3. Things to Avoid When Buying A New Window 

When it comes to buying a new window, there are a few common mistakes that people make. Here are four of the most common mistakes to avoid when shopping for a new window:

Not Measuring Twice (or More)

This is probably the most common mistake people make when buying a new window. Always measure your space multiple times before ordering a window. This will help ensure that you get the right size window for your space.

Assuming all Windows are the Same

Not all windows are created equal. There are many different types and styles of windows on the market, so it’s important to do your research before settling on one.

Not Checking for Warranties

Always check to see if the window you’re interested in comes with a warranty. This can save you a lot of money down the line if something goes wrong with the window.

The thing to avoid when buying a new window is not checking for warranties

Not Getting Professional Installation

Unless you’re a professional yourself, it’s always best to hire someone to install your new window. This will help ensure that the window is installed correctly and will help avoid any potential problems.

Following these simple tips will help you avoid making common mistakes when buying a new window. By taking your time and doing your research, you can be sure to find the perfect window for your home.

Don’t settle for the first window brand you come across. Just because a company is the biggest or most well-known doesn’t mean it makes the best windows. Do your research to find the best brand for your needs.

There are a few brands that consistently rank as some of the worst in the industry. Avoid these companies if you want a quality product that will last.

4. Worst window brands to avoid 

There are several window brands that you should avoid because they are known for being low quality and unreliable. Some of the worst window brands to avoid include:

4.1. Amcraft

Amcraft windows are often installed in homes that have low-quality construction. The windows don’t always fit well and they can be difficult to operate. Their windows are not energy efficient. They do not have a good warranty program.

Amcraft windows are often installed in homes that have low-quality construction

Related: Detailed Review of Amcraft Windows

4.2. American Craftsman

They are known to have manufacturing defects that cause windows to warp and crack.

In addition, their customer service is poor and they have been known to be unresponsive to warranty claims.

Lastly, their windows are overpriced compared to other brands.

American Craftsman has been known to be unresponsive to warranty claims

Related: American Craftsman Windows: Quality and Design Issues

4.3. MI windows

MI is one of the worst window brands. They have terrible customer service, and their windows are known to break easily. Their products are often unreliable and don’t last as long as they should.

The company has a poor customer service record and is difficult to work with if something goes wrong. Their windows are also quite expensive compared to other brands.

MI windows are also quite expensive compared to other brands

Learn more: MI Windows Reviews

4.4. Atrium

The Atrium is known for its low-quality windows. They’re often considered one of the worst window brands on the market. Their products are prone to cracking and leaking, which can lead to a host of other problems like moisture damage and higher energy bills.

The Atrium is known for its low-quality windows

Read more: Atrium Windows Reviews

4.5. Crestline

Crestline is one of the worst window brands because their windows are poorly made and they have terrible customer service. Their windows are often leaking and drafty, and their customer service is unresponsive and unhelpful. We do not recommend Crestline windows.

Crestline windows are poorly made and have terrible customer service

4.6. Lincoln

Lincoln is one of the worst window brands because they have a history of poor-quality products. In addition, their customer service is notoriously bad. If you have any problems with your windows, it will be difficult to get help from Lincoln.

• Lincoln windows are expensive and they do not last long.
• The company does not have a good warranty policy.
• Lincoln windows are often installed improperly.

Lincoln windows are expensive and they do not last long

4.7. Woodbridge

Why Woodbridge is bad? There have been many reports of windows being installed incorrectly, which can cause serious damage to a home. There have also been reports of the windows leaking, which can lead to mold and mildew problems.

Woodbridge windows leaking lead to mold and mildew problems

Read more Woodbridge windows reviews

4.8. Window World

Window World is one of the worst window brands because they have a terrible reputation for customer service.

In addition, their windows are often made with low-quality materials and don’t perform well in cold weather climates. 

Other than that, their prices are also quite high when compared to other window brands.

Window World has a terrible reputation for customer service

5. How to Choose the Best Window Replacement Brands

Window Options

Not all window replacement companies are the same. Each company offers a specific range of window types and styles. Therefore, it is crucial to identify the type of window you desire and ensure its compatibility with your home when deciding on the most suitable company.

Some companies exclusively sell and install windows, while others manufacture the windows they sell and install.

Repair or Replacement

In certain instances, it may be feasible to repair specific issues with existing windows rather than opting for a complete replacement. Some companies extend repair services alongside full installations. Thus, it is advisable to have your windows inspected by a repair technician before committing to a new window entirely.

However, there are cases where repairs are not viable, and a replacement becomes necessary. A reputable and knowledgeable company should be able to assess the situation and recommend the most suitable course of action.

Have your windows inspected by a repair technician before buying a new window

Established Reputation

When choosing a company for home improvement, assessing its reputation for quality, customer service, and affordability is paramount. Reading customer reviews is an effective way to gauge a company’s standing.

The Better Business Bureau website provides review ratings and insights into how companies handle customer complaints, with an A+ BBB grade signifying a high level of responsiveness and issue resolution.

Customer Service

Effective customer service with the window company is crucial. Understanding the company’s preferred communication methods, such as email, phone, text, or chat, is important. Consider your communication preferences and select a company that aligns with them. Some companies even offer 24-hour telephone hotlines and live chat options for added convenience.

Effective customer service is crucial

Cost and Financing Options

Window replacement costs can vary significantly, ranging from $200 to $1,200 per window. To ensure affordability, inquire about costs with your chosen company and explore any available deals or promotions. 

Some companies provide financing options with lower interest rates or deferred interest for a specified period. While caution is advised with deferred financing, other promotions, such as seasonal rebates or early booking discounts, may be worthwhile for customers seeking cost-effective solutions.

6. How do we choose the best window brands 

Windows Sizes

In general, window prices escalate with size. When evaluating costs from different providers, consider size-dependent pricing in your decision-making process. It’s crucial to ensure that replacement windows match the specific spaces in your home, so selecting a company that provides or can customize the necessary window size and type is essential.

Choose the suitable window size for your home

Window Materials

A variety of materials, including vinyl, wood, aluminum, fiberglass, composites, and specialized compounds, are accessible for replacement windows. Options for materials similar to your existing windows or seize the opportunity to transition to a more efficient or aesthetically pleasing material and design.

While vinyl is the most prevalent, aluminum replacement windows are not as popular due to their lower energy efficiency compared to vinyl, which is both cost-effective and efficient.

Fiberglass and composites, though somewhat more expensive, provide excellent color options and durability. Wood replacement windows offer an authentic appearance and can complement almost any home style.

Warranty Coverage

Considering that windows stay in your home for many years, the warranty ought to meet your satisfaction. Warranties differ in duration, covering aspects such as a window’s expected lifespan, parts, glass, seals, defects, and labor. Few warranties cover all these components for the same duration. If you plan to sell your home before the warranty expires, a transferable option can be a valuable selling point.

The warranty should meet your satisfaction

Color Options

Mismatched window colors can appear out of place in a home, especially when trying to match an older or distinctive style. Some replacement window manufacturers offer an extensive range of color choices, while others provide a selection of neutral colors designed to complement various home styles. Choose a window company that can accommodate the color options that suit your home best.

Energy Efficiency

Enhancing energy efficiency is a key reason for upgrading home windows. Look for features such as low U-factors, air leakage ratings, a low solar heat gain coefficient, condensation resistance, and light or visible transmittance. Balancing high efficiency with your budget is essential, as window prices typically increase with higher efficiency ratings.

Expert Advice

When selecting a window brand for your home, homeowners should consider factors such as durability, energy efficiency, and warranty. Pella and Andersen are two reputable brands that stand out in these areas. Pella is known for its robust product line and excellent customer service, while Andersen is renowned for its energy-efficient windows and extensive warranty.

In a nutshell, “For long-lasting reliability, Pella and Andersen windows offer superior durability and energy efficiency. Their commitment to customer satisfaction is evident in their excellent service and comprehensive warranties.”

Compare Top Window Brands

• JELD-WEN vs. Pella

FAQs – Frequently Asking Questions

Are Jeld Wen windows considered good? 

Jeld Wen windows can be a bit more expensive than some other brands, but they also offer a wide range of styles and options to choose from. They are a good choice for those who want a high-quality window that will last for many years.

What kind of window lasts the longest?

Vinyl windows exhibit exceptional durability, capable of withstanding diverse climates, rendering them among the most enduring window options available. Nonetheless, it’s worth noting that, with appropriate care and maintenance, the majority of windows can endure for a span of 15 to 30 years.

Vinyl windows are more durable than others

How much does it cost to install Windows?

Typically, the cost of window installation hovers around $600 per window, specifically for a mid-range double-hung window. However, this cost can vary widely, ranging from $200 to $1,200 per window. When factoring in labor expenses, you can anticipate spending anywhere from $100 to $300 per window, or approximately $40 if hiring a window installation contractor.

Is Marvin known for producing high-quality windows? 

Marvin windows are a good choice for those who want a high-quality window that will last for many years. They offer a wide range of styles and options to choose from, and they are known for their durability.

Is Marvin Windows better than Anderson? 

There is no definitive answer to this question as both window brands have their pros and cons. Marvin Windows are known for being more expensive than Anderson Windows, but they also tend to be of a higher quality. Anderson Windows are less expensive, but may not last as long. Ultimately, the best decision will depend on your specific needs and budget.

Marvin Windows is more expensive than Anderson Windows

Marvin windows are widely considered to be some of the best in the business. They’re known for their high-quality construction and durability. If you can afford them, Marvin windows are worth the investment.

Anderson windows are a more affordable option, but they don’t tend to last as long as Marvin windows. If you’re on a budget, Anderson Windows may be a good choice for you.

Do Pella windows cost more than Marvin? 

Pella windows are generally more expensive than Marvin windows. However, both brands offer a variety of window types and styles to choose from, so it’s important to compare prices before making a purchase. Pella also offers a wider range of customization options than Marvin.

When it comes to energy efficiency, both Pella and Marvin windows are excellent choices. Both brands offer a variety of energy-efficient windows, including double- and triple-paned windows.

How do replacement windows differ from new windows?

Windows designed for new installations are crafted for openings in homes where no trim or siding is yet in place. These new windows typically feature nailing, attachment fins, or flanges on their exterior. In contrast, replacement windows are specifically designed for existing window spaces, providing a tailored fit to replace the original windows without requiring extensive modifications.

New windows need feature nailing, attachment fins, or flanges on their exterior

Who makes American Craftsman windows? 

The company is known as Andersen Corporation. They’re a large manufacturer of windows and doors, with a wide range of products available. American Craftsman is one of their most popular lines, offering high-quality windows at an affordable price.

Are Quaker windows good? 

I was recently looking at some Quaker windows and I wasn’t sure if they were good quality or not. I found that they had a lot of positive reviews, but I also found some complaints about them as well.

Overall, I think that they are a good window company and their products are of good quality. However, there are some cheaper window companies out there that might be a better option for some people.

So there you have it, the worst and best window brands. We hope this information was helpful to you in making a decision on which windows to buy for your home. As always, feel free to contact us if you have any questions. We’re here to help!

What are your thoughts? Have you had experience with any of these window brands? Let us know in the comments below.